Home Run Promises and US Heart Transplant Odds

A small wooden baseball bat lying in clover on a sunlit lawn.

Last checked · Suggest a correction

On May 15, 2009, an 18 year old patient named Alyssa, who had been waiting 107 days for a heart transplant at NewYork-Presbyterian Morgan Stanley Children’s Hospital, met New York Yankees outfielder Brett Gardner at a hospital event and gave him a bracelet, telling him that if he held onto it, he was going to hit a home run. Brett Gardner homered on May 15, 2009, hours after a teen awaiting a heart transplant gave him a bracelet; by our arithmetic, the odds were about 1 in 76.67.

The visit was organized by Project Sunshine, a nonprofit whose volunteers visit children facing medical challenges. The very next morning, Alyssa received a successful heart transplant at the same hospital, according to its release.

What happened in the game

Gardner did not start that night against the Minnesota Twins. Johnny Damon was ejected in the bottom of the 3rd inning, and Gardner replaced him in the top of the 4th, batting 2nd and playing center field. He came to the plate three times.

InningGardner’s plate appearanceScore after the play (Twins, Yankees)
5thSingle on a line drive to center field3, 1
7thInside the park home run on a line drive to left field, his 2nd of 20094, 2
9thTriple on a fly ball to right field to lead off the inning4, 2
Source: MLB Stats API play by play, game 244730, Minnesota Twins at New York Yankees, May 15, 2009.

Gardner’s triple led off the bottom of the 9th with the Yankees trailing 4 to 2, and he scored on Mark Teixeira’s single. Melky Cabrera’s single later in the inning drove in two runs for a 5 to 4 Yankees win. The hospital’s release called Gardner’s home run the first inside the park home run by a Yankees player in nearly ten years.

How unlikely was the home run?

Gardner was not a power hitter at the time. Before that game, he had 1 home run in 229 major league plate appearances: none in 141 plate appearances in 2008, and 1 in 88 plate appearances in 2009 through May 14 (our arithmetic from the 2009 game log). That one home run had come two days earlier, against the Toronto Blue Jays on May 13.

At 1 home run per 229 plate appearances, the chance of at least one home run in 3 plate appearances is 1 minus (228/229) cubed, about 1.30%, or 1 in 76.67 (our arithmetic).

SpanPlate appearancesHome runsPlate appearances per home run (our arithmetic)
2008 season1410none hit
2009 through May 1488188
Career before May 15, 20092291229
2009 season284394.67
Career, 2008 to 20216,61413947.58
Source: MLB Stats API, Brett Gardner (player 458731) year by year, career and 2009 game log hitting stats; Book of Odds calculations.

He finished 2009 with 3 home runs in 284 plate appearances, and over a career spent entirely with the Yankees from 2008 to 2021 he hit 139 home runs in 6,614 plate appearances, about 1 every 47.58 (our arithmetic).

How many heart transplants happen in the US?

Alyssa’s transplant was one of a growing number. In 2024, heart transplants in the United States reached a record 4,636, an 81.5% increase since 2013, according to the OPTN/SRTR 2024 Annual Data Report. Of those, 4,146 were in adults and 490 in pediatric recipients, about 10.57% (our arithmetic).

Measure (US)AdultsPediatric recipients
Heart transplants in 20244,146490
Increase since 201393.5%19.2%
Survival 1 year after transplant (transplants in 2017 to 2019)91.2%92.3%
Survival 5 years after transplant (transplants in 2017 to 2019)80.1%83.9%
Deaths before transplant per 100 patient years on the waiting list8.48.2
Source: OPTN/SRTR 2024 Annual Data Report: Heart, American Journal of Transplantation, June 2026 (PubMed 42276700).

The report says survival after transplant remained stable, while deaths before transplant declined slightly in adults and reached a 10 year low among pediatric candidates. Across all organs, UNOS reports that 49,064 organ transplants were performed nationwide in 2025.

The promise that came first: Babe Ruth in 1926

Gardner’s story echoes one of baseball’s oldest legends. In 1926, Johnny Sylvester was an 11 year old Yankees fan in Essex Fells, New Jersey, who became seriously ill after a horseback riding accident, according to Princeton University’s archives. Babe Ruth sent him autographed balls and a note: “I’ll knock a homer for you on Wednesday.”

On Wednesday, October 6, 1926, in Game 4 of the World Series at Sportsman’s Park in St. Louis, Ruth hit three home runs in a 10 to 5 Yankees win over the Cardinals. The Society for American Baseball Research (SABR) notes that he became the first player to hit three homers in a postseason game, and the win evened the Series at two games apiece. Princeton’s archives add that there is some disagreement in the historical record about how critically ill Sylvester was, and that his condition improved greatly after the game; he graduated from Princeton in 1937.

The short version

On May 15, 2009, 18 year old transplant candidate Alyssa gave Brett Gardner a bracelet and predicted a home run; that night he hit an inside the park home run, and the next morning she received a heart transplant. With 1 home run in 229 career plate appearances before the game, his chance of homering in 3 plate appearances was about 1 in 76.67 (our arithmetic). In 2024, the US performed a record 4,636 heart transplants.

Last checked: October 29, 2026, against the MLB Stats API record of the May 15, 2009 Twins and Yankees game and Brett Gardner’s hitting stats, NewYork-Presbyterian’s June 11, 2009 release, the OPTN/SRTR 2024 Annual Data Report: Heart, UNOS 2025 transplant totals, and the Princeton, Retrosheet and SABR accounts of October 6, 1926. This article was machine-checked against the sources above and has not been expert-reviewed. Spotted an error or a newer public figure? Please tell us on our contact page with the article link and we will review it.

✱ The Outlier

Be the interesting one at dinner.

One email. A few surprising odds. Plenty to talk about.

Email signup opens soon.

Sources

What changed
  • Updated with the MLB Stats API record of the May 15, 2009 game and Brett Gardner's hitting stats, the hospital's June 11, 2009 release, the OPTN/SRTR 2024 heart report, UNOS 2025 transplant totals, and Princeton, Retrosheet and SABR accounts of October 6, 1926. The old page's figures of 1 home run in 229 plate appearances and 1 in 76.67 odds are confirmed. It also said Gardner visited with Babe Ruth's granddaughter Linda Ruth Tosetti, called the hit the first inside the park home run in the new Yankee Stadium, said a donor heart became available around the time he crossed home plate, cited 1 in 1.2 (83.3%) heart candidates receiving a transplant within a year, 68% at NewYork-Presbyterian and a 0.3% chance of a transplant that day, and said Gardner sat mostly on the bench in the 2009 playoffs and kept the bracelet in his locker; those earlier figures and passages are superseded. The original page was posted by David Gassko.

✱ The Outlier

Be the interesting one at dinner.

One email. A few surprising odds. Plenty to talk about.

Email signup opens soon.